DWARF Standard


090303.1 Kendrick Wong Support C++0x strongly typed enumerations Enhancement Accepted with modifications Kendrick Wong


For a detailed description of the feature, please refer to:



Current C++ enums are not type-safe. This is because an enumeration type is 
promoted to an integer by integral promotion.

enum Color { ClrRed, ClrOrange, ClrYellow, ClrGreen, ClrBlue, ClrViolet };
enum Alert { CndGreen, CndYellow, CndRed };
Color c = ClrRed;
Alert a = CndGreen;

bool armWeapons = ( a >= ClrYellow );     // Compiles okay, but not desirable

A new strongly-type enum is therefore created: enum class. There is no implicit 
conversion between enum class and int. And the underlying type is always well-specified.

enum class A { A1=1 };                 // underlying type is int by default
enum class B: unsigned long { B1=1 };  // underlying type is unsigned long

enum class introduces its own scope. The names of enumerators are in the enum’s 
scope, and are not injected into the enclosing scope.

enum class E { E1, E2, E3 = 100, E4 /* = 101 */ };
E e1 = E1;      // error
E e2 = E::E2;   // ok

Proposed change to DWARF

New DWARF attribute
DW_AT_enum_class   0x70   flag   A strongly typed enumeration type 

5.8 Enumeration Type Entries

If an enumeration type has type-safe semantics such that:

    * enumerators are contained in the scope of the enumeration type
    * enumerators do not implicitly convert to or from another type

then the enumeration type may have a DW_AT_enum_class attribute 
specifying those semantics. The value of this attribute is a flag.

In C++, a type declared using enum class is a 'strongly typed 
enumeration type', and would be represented with this attribute.

enum class E { E1, E2=100 };
E e1;
11$:  DW_TAG_enumeration_type
          DW_AT_type(reference to base type "int")
12$:      DW_TAG_enumerator
13$:      DW_TAG_enumerator
14$:  DW_TAG_variable
          DW_AT_type(reference to 11$)

Change History

May 7, 2009.
    * Remove DW_TAG_strong_enumueration_type, in favor of DW_AT_enum_class
    * Update example to use new attribute.
    * Update 5.8 to describe strongly typed enumeration with DW_AT_enum_class

June 3, 2009.
    * Reword 5.8 to remove C++0x from normative text

June 8, 2009.
    * John Bishop suggests alternate wording for 5.8. (With normative text in front)

July 2, 2009.

    * David Gross suggests replacing "enumeration elements" with "enumerators"
    * David Gross pointed out correct indentation for "DW_TAG_enumerator".


August 11, 2009 -- Accepted, with non-normative text changed to "when there is 
only one semantic for enumerations in the language, this attribute is not needed".

All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner.
The comments are property of their posters, all the rest © 2007-2017 by DWARF Standards Committee.